Lock him in the dungeon

With the pathetic, little wimp defeated, you take him away to the Order's dungeon. Locked in the underground cells, he is awaiting trial for allowing overly lewd stuff to happen on these peaceful lands. Unfortunately for him though, due to the ongoing war, all judges are on the frontline and he will be waiting... indefinitely. In the meantime, he might get visits from the wardens who like to tease the fuck out of their prisoners until they break and accept all charges, forcing them to be a slave to the Hero who defeated them. After all, you did beat him and you deserve your slave...